Skip to main content

NUET 2024

NUET 2024 was supported by the RTG “Dynamics: Classical, Modern, and Quantum”.  Its Summer School was held July 29-August 2, 2024 and its conference was held August 5-9, 2024.  All events were held on Northwestern University’s Evanston campus. The Summer School introduced early graduate students to modern ergodic theory and prepares them for the conference NU Trends in Ergodic Theory. The school covered several aspects of modern ergodic theory at a level suitable for those with a background in analysis. The conference brought together researchers working on many aspects of ergodic theory, aimed to encourage interactions between young researchers and research leaders, and communicated new techniques to the community.

The NUET 2024 organizers were Bryna Kra (Northwestern University), Joel Moreira (University of Warwick), Florian Richter (Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Lausanne), Donald Robertson (University of Manchester), and Bradley Zykoski (Northwestern University)

Summer School Speakers and Mini-Courses

Vitaly Bergelson (The Ohio State University): The dynamical underpinnings of some old and new results in combinatorics and number theory

Sebastian Donoso (University of Chile) and Anh Le (University of Denver): Introduction to Multiple Ergodic Averages: Nilpotent Structures, Recurrence, and New Challenges

Rachel Greenfeld (Northwestern University): Two Approaches to Translational Tilings: Combinatorial and Ergodic Theoretic

Wenbo Sun (Virginia Tech): Spherical higher order Fourier analysis

NUET 2024 Conference Speakers
Ethan Ackelsberg (École polytechnique fédérale de Lausanne)
  • Title: Polynomial sumset configurations in the integers
  • Abstract: Answering a question of Erdős, Kra—Moreira—Richter—Roberston showed that every positive density subset of the integers contains a shift of a sumset configuration {b1 + b2 : b1 ≠ b2 ∈ B} for some infinite set B. I will address a polynomial variant of this problem: does every set of positive density in the integers contain a shift of a polynomial sumset configuration {p(b1) + b2 : b1 < b2 ∈ B} for some infinite set B, where p is a given intersective polynomial?

Tim Austin (University of Warwick)

  • Title:  Modern notions of entropy in ergodic theory and representation theory.
  • Abstract:  Shannon introduced entropy for discrete random variables in his foundational work on information theory.  Within about a decade Kolmogorov and Sinai had adapted it to the study of general measure-preserving systems in ergodic theory.  Many variants and other applications have appeared since, connecting probability, combinatorics, dynamics and other areas. I will survey a few recent developments in this story.  I will focus largely on (i) Lewis Bowen's "sofic entropy", which helps us to study the dynamics of "large" groups such as free groups, and (ii) a cousin of sofic entropy in the world of unitary representations, which leads to new connections with operator algebras and random matrices.
Vitaly Bergelson (The Ohio State University)
  • Title: New results on the independence of polynomial actions involving strongly mixing transformations.
  • Abstract:  The purpose of this talk is to discuss some new polynomial ergodic theorems for commuting strongly mixing measure preserving transformations. (Joint work with Rigo Zelada).
Pablo Candela (Autonomous University of Madrid)
  • Title: Nilspace systems, Abramov systems, and a question of Jamneshan--Shalom--Tao
  • Abstract: A measure-preserving $G$-system $X$ is said to be an Abramov system of order $\leq k$ if the linear span of the polynomial phase functions of degree $\leq k$ on $X$ is dense in $L^2(X)$. Abramov systems feature prominently in the ergodic-theoretic approach of Bergelson--Tao--Ziegler to the inverse theorem for Gowers norms on vector spaces $\mathbb{F}_p^n$. A central part of this approach is the analysis of the Host--Kra factors of $G$-systems with $G$ equal to the (additive group of the) infinite-dimensional vector space $\mathbb{F}_p^\omega$. An appealing conjecture, which was proved by Bergelson--Tao--Ziegler in the high characteristic case but left open in low characteristic, was whether every ergodic $\mathbb{F}_p^\omega$-system of order k (i.e. isomorphic to its k-th Host--Kra factor) is Abramov of order $\leq k$. More recently, Jamneshan, Shalom and Tao disproved this conjecture, and raised an interesting follow-up question: is every ergodic $\mathbb{F}_p^\omega$-system of order $k$ a factor of some Abramov system of order $\leq k$. I will discuss a positive answer to this question given in recent joint work with González-Sánchez and Szegedy. Our approach uses as a key ingredient a recent theory of certain dynamical systems which form a useful generalization of the classical nilsystems: the so-called nilspace systems. The talk will thus be an opportunity also to discuss some central aspects, applications and questions of this recent theory.
Sebastian Donoso (University of Chile)
  • Title: The joint transitivity property.
  • Abstract: In recent years, the joint ergodicity property, which states that averages of $T_1^{a_1(n)}f_1 \cdots T_k^{a_k(n)}f_k$ converge (in the $L^2$ norm) to the product $\prod_{i=1}^{k} \int f_i d\mu$, has been extensively investigated in ergodic theory. The talk will focus on an analogous property in the topological dynamics setting, referred to as $\Delta$-transitivity or joint transitivity. The problem is to determine conditions under which the sequence $(T_1^{a_1(n)}x, \ldots, T_k^{a_k(n)}x)_{n\in \mathbb{N}$ is dense in $X^k$ for a dense set of $x \in X$. In recent work with Andreas Koutsogiannis and Wenbo Sun, we established conditions under which the sequence $(T_1^n,T_2^n,\ldots,T_d^n)$ is jointly transitive. In this talk, we will review the main ideas of the proof and, if time allows, state possible future questions and directions.
Nikos Frantzikinakis (University of Crete)
  • Title: Partition regularity of Pythagorean pairs and more
  • Abstract: An important question in arithmetic Ramsey theory is whether Pythagorean triples are partition regular, i.e. whether every partition of the integers into finitely many pieces contains solutions of the equation  $x^2+y^2=z^2$, where x,y,z belong to the same cell of the partition. I will present a recent result where we prove partition regularity of Pythagorean pairs, i.e. we can guarantee that there are two numbers x,y in the same cell of the partition such that $x^2+y^2=z^2$ for some integer z that can be in another cell (and a similar result with x,z instead of x,y). After some initial maneuvers inspired by ergodic theory, the proof consists in studying the asymptotic behavior of bounded multiplicative functions, and their products, along certain binary quadratic forms. This is a problem of independent interest that we solved using a combination of tools such as Gowers uniformity, to cover the random-like case, and concentration estimates, to cover the structured case. I will also present some recent developments concerning more general homogeneous quadratic equations in three variables. This is  joint work with O. Klurman and J. Moreira.
Rachel Greenfeld (Northwestern University)
  • Title: The tiling mystery
  • Abstract: A tiling (or monotiling) is a covering of a space using copies of one building block, called a tile, without any overlaps.  For instance, a planar tiling can be as boring as a regular square tilling or as interesting as the Escher lizard tiling or even the recently discovered aperiodic hat tiling.  There seems to be a mysterious divide between "structured'' tiling problems, in which the tilings are well behaved, to "wild'' tiling problems, where almost anything can happen; e.g., translational tilings vs. isometric tilings, low dimension tilings vs. high dimension tilings, discrete tilings vs. continuous tilings.  In the talk we will discuss this phenomenon, and present some recent progress towards solving the mystery of the structure of tilings.
Wen Huang (University of Science and Technology of China)
  • Title: Multiple Recurrence without commutativity
  • Abstract: Furstenberg's multiply recurrent theorem states that any dynamical system has multiply recurrent points. In this talk, we discuss multiple Recurrence without commutativity. More precisely, Let $(X,T)$ and $(X,S)$ be two minimal systems. It turns out that there is a residual subset $X_0$ of $X$ such that for any $x\in X_0$ and any finite nonlinear integral polynomials $p_1,\ldots, p_d$ vanishing at $0$, there is some subsequence $\{n_i\}$ of $\mathbb{N}$ with $n_i\to\infty$ satisfying $$  S^{n_i}x\to x,\ T^{p_1(n_i)}x\to x, \ldots,\ T^{p_d(n_i)}x\to x,\ i\to\infty.$$ This based on joint works with Prof. Song Shao and Xiangdong Ye.
Asgar Jamneshan (Koç University)
  • Title: Structural results for bounded torsion actions and applications to inverse Gowers theory
  • Abstract: This talk consists of two parts: the first presented by myself and the second by Or, both parts featuring joint work with Terence Tao. In the first part, we review structural results concerning Host--Kra--Ziegler factors of \( F_p^\omega \)-systems and the corresponding inverse Gowers theory of finite vector spaces due to Bergelson, Tao, and Ziegler. Specifically, we provide a counterexample to a conjecture by Bergelson, Tao, and Ziegler regarding the Abramov property of such factors. We conclude the first part with a discussion and speculation on the implications of the counterexample and the connection to the combinatorial theory. In the second part, we delve into the structure theory of the more general setting of totally disconnected Host--Kra--Ziegler factors and the inverse Gowers theory of bounded torsion groups. Additionally, we examine the opposite case of connected Host--Kra--Ziegler factors and its relationship to the Green--Tao--Ziegler inverse theorem for cyclic groups. These results pave the way for a potential unified inverse Gowers theorem that incorporates both cyclic groups and bounded torsion groups.
Adam Kanigowski (University of Maryland)
  • Title: Horocycle orbits at sparse times
  • Abstract: We discuss the orbits of the horocycle flow acting on X = SL(2,R)/Γ when sampled at sparse subsets of the integers. We will focus on the case of polynomial (sub-quadratic) times and also at numbers which are products of at most two prime numbers. We will show that for every δ >0 the orbit {h_(n^(2−δ)) x} is dense for every non-periodic point x ∈ SL(2,R)/SL(2,Z) (joint work with M. Radziwill). We will also show that if Γ is arithmetic, then {h_(p·q) x}_(p,q−primes) equidistributes towards the only invariant measure on the regular orbit when sampled over Z (joint with G. Forni, M. Radziwill).
Andreas Koutsogiannis (Aristotle University of Thessaloniki)
  • Title: Ergodic averages along primes
  • Abstract: We discuss norm-convergence results for multiple ergodic averages along sequences of polynomial growth evaluated at primes. We do so by comparing the latter averages with the corresponding ones along positive integers. Combining our results with Furstenberg's correspondence principle, we derive several applications in combinatorics. Namely, we show that positive density subsets of positive integers contain arbitrarily long arithmetic progressions with common difference coming from the aforementioned sequences evaluated at primes (or shifted primes), obtaining far-reaching extensions to Szemerédi’s theorem. One of the main tools in the proof, that covers the polynomial sequences case, is the uniformity of the von Mangoldt function in intervals of the form $[1,N]$ which follows from a result of Green and Tao, and, for sparse sequences, a recent result of Matomäki, Shao, Tao, and Teräväinen on the uniformity of the stated function in short intervals. We will present results of individual and joint (with Dimitris Karageorgos, and Konstantinos Tsinas) work.
Ben Krause (University of Bristol)
  • Title: 90 years of pointwise ergodic theory
  • Abstract: In this talk I will discuss the highlights of pointwise ergodic theory, beginning with the work of Birkhoff in the 1930s, then turning to the seminal work of Bourgain in the late 80s-early 90s, and concluding with more modern work, joint with Mirek and Tao.
Borys Kuca (Jagiellonian University)
  • Title: Polynomial corners and quantitative concatenation
  • Abstract: The utility of ergodic methods in additive combinatorics lies primarily in their robustness: no other approach has so far managed to detect as many patterns in dense sets of integers as the ergodic one. This however comes at a price: ergodic theory is incapable of providing quantitative information on the size of finite sets avoiding a given pattern. The last decade has witnessed considerable progress in narrowing the gap between what we know qualitatively and quantitatively thanks to an outpour of new bounds in the polynomial Szemerédi theorem of Bergelson and Leibman. In this talk, I will present two papers written jointly with Noah Kravitz and James Leng in which we contribute to this program of quantifying the polynomial Szemerédi theorem. Specifically, I will discuss our recent bounds for sets with no polynomial corners, one of the simplest 2-dimensional polynomial configurations. While the result is more combinatorial than ergodic, a substantial part of the toolbox that we develop has applications to ergodic theory.
Anh Le (University of Denver)
  • Title: Dynamically central syndetic sets and sets of pointwise recurrence
  • Abstract: A subset of the positive integers is dynamically central syndetic if it contains the times of return of a point to a neighborhood of itself in a minimal dynamical system. This class of syndetic sets forms an important bridge between dynamics and combinatorics.  We show that a set is dynamically central syndetic if and only if it is a member of a syndetic, idempotent filter.  We elaborate on the consequences of this characterization for the dual family (sets of pointwise recurrence) and the localized dual family (dynamically central piecewise syndetic sets).  For example, we provide several combinatorial characterizations of sets of pointwise recurrence, show that these sets do not have the Ramsey property, and they are sets of measurable multiple polynomial recurrence for commuting transformations. These results answer several questions asked by Host, Kra, and Maass. This talk is based on an ongoing joint work with Daniel Glasscock (University of Massachusetts Lowell).
Alejandro Maass (University of Chile)
  • Title: Directional dynamical cubes for minimal Zd-systems
  • Abstract: In this talk, we discuss the notions of directional dynamical cubes and directional regionally proximal relation defined via these cubes for a minimal $Z^d$-system $(X, T_1,. . . , T_d )$. We discuss the structural properties of systems that satisfy the so-called unique closing parallelepiped property and we characterize them in several ways. In the distal case, we build the maximal factor of a $Z^d$-system $(X, T_1, . . . , T_d )$ that satisfies this property by taking the quotient with respect to the directional regionally proximal relation. Finally, we completely describe distal $Z^d$-systems that enjoy the unique closing parallelepiped property and provide explicit examples.
Mariusz Mirek (Rutgers University)
  • Title: Recent progress in nilpotent pointwise ergodic theory.
  • Abstract: The aim of this talk is to report on recent progress in pointwise almost everywhere convergence for ergodic averages along polynomial sequences in nilpotent groups of step two of measure-preserving transformations on probability spaces. In particular, we will discuss a nilpotent circle method that enables us to utilize certain ideas from the classical circle method in nilpotent groups. We will also introduce almost-orthogonality techniques that go beyond Fourier transform methods, which are not suitable in the non-commutative, nilpotent framework.
Sarah Peluse (University of Michigan)
  • Title: Sqorners
  • Abstract: I'll talk about recent work with Sean Prendiville and Fernando Shao in which we prove the first quantitative bounds in Bergelson—Leibman’s multidimensional polynomial Szemer\’edi theorem for the configuration (x,y), (x,y+d), (x+d^2,y), which we call “sqorners”. We also prove a “popular difference” version of this result, with effective bounds.
Or Shalom (Institute of Advanced Studies)
  • Title: Structural results for bounded torsion actions and applications to inverse Gowers theory
  • Abstract: This talk consists of two parts: the first presented by Asgar and the second by myself, both parts featuring joint work with Terence Tao. In the first part, we review structural results concerning Host--Kra--Ziegler factors of \mathbb{F}_p^\omega-systems and the corresponding inverse Gowers theory of finite vector spaces due to Bergelson, Tao, and Ziegler. Specifically, we provide a counterexample to a conjecture by Bergelson, Tao, and Ziegler regarding the Abramov property of such factors. We conclude the first part with a discussion and speculation on the implications of the counterexample and the connection to the combinatorial theory. In the second part, we delve into the structure theory of the more general setting of totally disconnected Host--Kra--Ziegler factors and the inverse Gowers theory of bounded torsion groups. Additionally, we examine the opposite case of connected Host--Kra--Ziegler factors and its relationship to the Green--Tao--Ziegler inverse theorem for cyclic groups. These results pave the way for a potential unified inverse Gowers theorem that incorporates both cyclic groups and bounded torsion groups.
Younghwan Son (Pohang University of Science and Technology)
  • Title: Joint Ergodicity of Piecewise Monotone Maps
  • Abstract: A map defined on the unit interval is called piecewise monotone if there exists a finite or countably infinite partition of pairwise disjoint subintervals such that the restriction of the map to each subinterval is monotone and continuous. In this talk, we explore the phenomenon of joint ergodicity of piecewise monotone maps. Specifically, under some natural conditions, piecewise monotone maps possessing distinct entropy values exhibit joint ergodicity. This means that the multiple ergodic averages regarding these maps converge to the product of their respective space averages. This is a joint work with Vitaly Bergelson.
Wenbo Sun (Virginia Tech)
  • Title: Geometry Ramsey Conjecture over finite fields
  • Abstract:  The Geometry Ramsey Conjecture is a question raised by Graham in 1994, which says that given any finite configuration X which lies on a sphere, for any finite coloring of the Euclidean space, there always exists a monochromatic congruent copy of tX for any large enough scaler t. One can also formulate a similar question for the finite field setting. While the study of the Geometry Ramsey Conjecture in literature focuses on the harmonic analysis approach, in this talk, we will explain how the higher order Fourier analysis method can be used to answer the Geometry Ramsey Conjecture in the finite field setting.
Joni Teräväinen (University of Turku)
  • Title: Multiple ergodic averages with prime and Möbius weights
  • Abstract: We discuss the pointwise convergence of multiple ergodic averages weighted by two arithmetic weights: the primes and the Möbius function. For the Möbius weight, we show that the averages converge pointwise for any polynomial iterates. For the prime case, in ongoing joint work with Krause, Mousavi and Tao, we obtain results for two polynomial iterates. For the proofs, recent quantitative bounds for the Gowers norms of these weights, due to Leng, play a key role.
Xiangdong Ye (University of Science and Technology of China)
  • Title: Saturation theorems for products and applications to independence
  • Abstract: The saturation theorems play crucial roles to deduce certain problems to the same ones on nilsystems. In this talk I will explain how to prove a saturation theorem for the product of finitely many minimal systems. Then I will give the applications of the theorem to problems related to independence. Namely, for a minimal system (X,T) and a factor map from X to its maximal d-step pronilfactor X_d, we explore the complexity of T on fibers in terms of independence. This is a joint work with Qiu Jiahao, Xu Hui and Yu Jiaqi.